In the athleisure world, we are pretty saturated with options. However, the prices can be steep and it is hard to tell which items are worth the investment. (Fun Fact: As of writing this post, I own 0 pairs of Lululemon, but I still love every pair I have!) So what’s the true difference between cheap versus expensive yoga pants, and how do you determine which ones are worth the splurge? Here, I provide my high-low analysis using two pairs I wear often.
Comparing The Fabric
Performance fabrics have technical features that are ideal for working out. Some common examples are: moisture-wicking, 4-way stretch, quick-drying, breathable.
While these features are desirable, they normally come at a higher price point because they require special technology to produce.
My higher-priced leggings from Athleta are made of a high-compression, moisture-wicking fabric. Very resilient. The lower-priced leggings from Old Navy, however, are made from a cotton-blend fabric. Still comfortable, but definitely does not wick sweat well. After a lot of movement, the leggings also begin to stretch out.
The difference is in the details: pockets!
Sounds cliché, but it’s true. My $90 Athleta Elation leggings come with a deep back pocket. When I go running outdoors, this feature is super helpful because I can stuff my keys and credit card in there, without worrying about them falling out. The Old Navy Balance leggings are super cute, but harder to wear outdoors if I need to store something.
It is not a big issue for me. But when comparing cheap versus expensive yoga pants, the latter wins for convenience!
Additional Details: The Waistband
To be fair, both options have a good waistband. I’ve done barré in both, and they don’t roll down at all. Both have classic fold-over waistbands, which from my experience are the most secure.
However, the Athleta Elation tights have a three-layer waistband. The rise is also higher, and sits snugly against my skin without any pinching. It feels supportive and stable.
The Old Navy Balance leggings are great as well, but have a simple two-layer fold-over waistband.
Final Detail: The Gusset
Okay, you are probably thinking what on Earth is a gusset?! I actually didn’t know either until I watched Netflix’s Explained episode on Athleisure. If you have not watched it, I highly recommend it!
A gusset is a triangular piece of fabric that sits between the crotch. It is designed to facilitate movement, and improve ventilation. Remember to look for this feature the next time you buy a pair of leggings!
Both pairs have a gusset—great! The more expensive option, however, is multi-layered with a mesh lining. The second option is just a double-layer using the same fabric as the body.
Social Responsibility & Certified B Corporation
Athleta and Old Navy are part of the same corporation (Gap Inc.). However, Athleta is a Certified B Corporation, whereas Old Navy is not. Brands with this certification commit to higher levels of social and environmental responsibility. This level of accountability ensures fair wages, and more sustainable sourcing decisions.
As of 2020, Athleta has committed to a goal of making 80% of fabrics sustainable. They have also empowered over 16,500 women through their P.A.C.E. and Fair Trade program. I don’t believe ‘sustainable’ fashion has to be expensive, but sometimes, the price we pay gives back to those who make it.
Shop this post
*This post contains affiliate links. If you make a purchase after clicking on a link, I may earn a small commission at no added cost to you.
Left: Old Navy Balance Leggings (only black available now); Right: Athleta 7/8 Elation Tights (similar).
Elation is one of Athleta’s core fabrics, so even if this one isn’t your style, there are plenty of designs to choose from throughout the year! This pair of Athleta 7/8 Elation Tight is the classic one available year-round. Also, while my Old Navy leggings were the cheaper option, they are still one of my favorites. Not perfect, of course. But I adapt what I wear to the exercise.
The Verdict
I wear both pairs pretty often, but the difference really comes down to the fabric, and design details. Generally when I compare cheap versus expensive yoga pants options, I find more expensive one to have more technical properties. However, considering I found my Old Navy pair for $3, I’m definitely not complaining about quality here 🙂 It does not wick sweat well, but can still be good for lower intensity exercises.
